← Insights
Capital

What your investors actually want (and what they don't)

Most founder–investor friction isn't a conflict of interest — it's a translation problem. Two smart people who want the same outcome, talking past each other for a year. Having sat in both chairs, here's the subtext.

Mark Ruddock
Mark Ruddock
Advisory Lead · 6 min read
What your investors actually want (and what they don't)

Most founder–investor friction isn't a conflict of interest. It's a translation problem — two smart people who want the same outcome, managing to talk past each other for a year. Having sat on both sides of the table, as a founder raising and as an investor and board member backing others, I've come to think the subtext is worth spelling out.

What investors actually want

  1. The truth, early. More than almost anything else, a good investor wants to hear the bad news while it's still small enough to help with. Bad news early beats good news late, every time. The founders who share problems before they're forced to are the ones who keep their board's trust through the inevitable rough patch.
  2. A founder who's coachable, not compliant. They didn't back you to hear their own ideas repeated. They backed your judgment. What they want is a founder who genuinely weighs input and then owns the call — not one who either ignores every suggestion or agrees with all of them.
  3. A clear line of sight to a real outcome. Not a hockey stick on a slide — a credible, specific story about how this becomes something that matters, and what has to be true along the way.
  4. To be used well. A good board member wants to be a resource, not an audience. Give them real problems to chew on and they'll bring you their best. Hand them a recap and they'll give you a rubber stamp.

What they don't want, whatever they say

  1. Surprises. The number that appears in the deck for the first time. The key executive who left a month ago. The competitor you didn't mention. Surprise is the fastest way to lose a board's confidence, and the slowest to earn it back.
  2. To run your company. Most good investors emphatically do not want your job — and the few who seem to want it are a warning, not a resource. Their leverage is judgment, not control.
  3. Spin. They've seen a hundred companies. They can smell a sandbagged number or a narrative doing the work the metrics won't. It reads as a tell, not a talent.

A note to the other side of the table

For the investors and board members reading this: the founders worth backing can tell the difference between a partner and a passenger inside two meetings. Bring judgment, not just capital. Be the call the founder actually wants to take when something's on fire — not the one they rehearse for. How you show up in the hard moments is your entire brand, and founders talk to each other.

The founder–investor relationship is a multi-year marriage entered into during a courtship designed to hide flaws.

The ones that work are built on the same thing every durable relationship is built on: candour, early and often. Everything else — the terms, the cadence, the governance — is just scaffolding around that.

Mark Ruddock
Written by
Mark RuddockAdvisory Lead, AFINEA

An internationally experienced CEO with three exits and over 20 years at the helm of VC-backed technology and fintech startups — as a founder and as a later-stage CEO brought in to scale — and an experienced board member.